Autumn in New York is not a great movie. I was nominated to write this review because I think it rises to the level of mediocre movie, and Pam does not agree. I'll start with some of the things that are wrong with it.
It does not
need Winona Ryder in the way that it needs Richard Gere. In this May-September romance, any number of women could have played the "May" role, though Our Noni did salvage some badly written scenes through sheer effort. (Some lines were beyond hope.)
But the September role requires an actor that almost every character can refer to as exceptionally good-looking for his age. And yes, those constant references and the ease with which Gere's character accepts them are part of what makes this not a great movie.
The other problem is predictability. (Insert half-hearted spoiler alert here, because everything you think it going to happen in this film is going to happen in this film.) IMDb called this a "romantic drama," which apparently means "romantic comedy with all of the usual plot points, except that someone dies."
The attraction between the main characters is, as Rod Stewart would say, purely physical. Because the pretext of their first date is a lie, it is no surprise that the inevitable break-up is also the result of a lie. The "boy gets girl back" moments -- I counted two - happen without even a moment's thought on the part of Noni's character or a hint of an apology. She is not even
awake for the first reunion.
Moreover, this movie badly fails the
Bechdel test, which required two named, female characters to discuss something other than a man. It would barely pass a modified Bechdel, in which two named, male characters discuss something other than Richard Gere's dimples.
So what, it is fair to ask, raises this film to the level of
mediocre? First, it is simply not as bad as I remember it from our first viewing years ago, nor is it as painful to watch as some of the other films we have reviewed recently in the one- and two-croquet-ball category. Second, although many scenes were cringe-worthy, I managed to care just enough about the characters to get a little misty when the surgeon -- played very well by
J.K. Simmons -- delivered the bad news we all knew was coming.
Finally, the whole film is easy on the eyes. Beautiful people, beautiful food (Gere plays a big-time chef with an implausibly lax work ethic), and most of all a beautiful autumn in New York. During a recent visit, our New Yorker friend Joe took us to this bridge, made famous by many movies, and clearly the strongest character in this one.
Final verdict: A scant three croquet balls -- good enough (barely) for non-fans